Transience - Nick Baines's blog - Musings of a restless bishop

Here goes with yet another exposure of ignorance.

Until this week I had never heard of the Spanish artist Cristobal Toral. Born in 1940 and from the Andalucian town of Antequera, he works in a variety of media. However, his paintings, bronzes and sculptures all address the pain and loneliness of transience. He seems obsessed with luggage. Yes – suitcases. And lonely people. Some of the female subjects of his paintings are the most poignant I have ever seen.

Core to his concerns are concepts of emigration – images of suitcases and a lone traveler. Emigration seems to him to characterise human experience both in reality and existentially. Hence his categorisation by people who know what they are talking about as a ‘realist’ who sees reality as a starting point and not a limitation. The result is powerful images suggestive of displacement, uncertainty and loneliness.

You have to stand in front of them to see what I mean by this. (I’d never make an art critic…)

For some obscure reason this reminded me of Bill Viola‘s Nantes Tryptich which I saw nearly a decade ago (I think) at Tate Modern in London. Viola filmed the last thirty minutes of his mother’s life and the last thirty minutes of his wife’s labour, placing the former on the right and the latter on the left (I think) of a central video of a human figure floating through water. It was haunting and disturbing. Yet, it was also compelling – attempting to hold his audience to just thirty minutes of contemplation of mortality and time in the midst of a race through an art gallery. (What interested me was how few people seemed able to stick with the Tryptich for more than just a few minutes of curious voyeurism.)

Ideas of transience are not exactly new. But, representations of transience that make you stop and look differently at it demand real skill. Viola asked us to contemplate our mortality; Toral stacks his suitcases and invites us to consider the human experience of ‘leaving’. They both made me stop and, in their different ways, provoked reflection on Cain – the experience of common humanity depicted in Genesis 4.

Having found himself exiled from Eden and stranded in a meaningless expanse of uncontoured desert (‘the Land of Nod’), Cain builds defensive walls, constructs a world of meaning within them. We all need constructs of significance that make our transient life meaningful and not meaningless. If we leave God behind we still need to create some sort of structure that allows us to believe that life is not worth nothing. Of course, the problem comes when the defensive walls of our constructed world view get breached by loss or chaos or crisis (existential or otherwise). The point is, however, that common to all human beings is the need for life to be inherently meaningful and not simply random or pointless.

I have yet to meet anyone who claims that life is inherently meaningless… and lives accordingly.

Christian faith begins with an acceptance of mortality, of transience. It starts with an experience of human being and living that faces death and non-existence with frankness and realism. But, as Easter is all about, it does so in the light of a meaning found in the action of God the Creator raising Christ from death and shining new light on our living and dying. It doesn’t minimise the experience of loss or crisis, but it does challenge fear and dread.

It also suggests that Christians should start with people’s real experience and not with answers to questions they haven’t yet formulated. Our common humanity is where we should always start – empathetically as well as intellectually – because it is here that we shall also always finish.

Views: 10

Tags: Andalucia, Antequera, Bill, Cristobal, Toral, Viola, art, existentialism

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Churches Together Connect to add comments!

Need help?

If you are having any difficulties with Churches Together Connect please contact us by email.


The views expressed on this website, or accessed through links, are those of the people and organisations concerned. CTBI as a charity does not necessarily share these views and accepts no responsibility for them.

Terms and Conditions

Churches Together Connect runs on the network and users are subject to its

Privacy policy

Report an Issue

Latest Activity

Katharina Smith-Muller posted a blog post

News/events (countrywide) - The celebration of Easter and Passover coincide this year

Our Jewish brothers and sisters have been celebrating the festival of Passover from 14th April, continuing until 22nd April. Pope Francis I. has sent a telegram expressing his good wishes for Passover to the Jewish community in Rome:" A few days on from our meeting, and with renewed gratitude for your having desired to honour the celebration of the beginning of my ministry with your presence and that of other distinguished members of the Jewish community, I take great pleasure in extending my…See More
Apr 16
Katharina Smith-Muller posted a blog post

Resources/events - Mahavir Jayanti and Vaisakhi

This coming long weekend brings not one, but two festivals of non-Christian religions – the Jain community celebrates Mahavir Jayanti on 13th April (Sunday), and the Sikh community celebrates Vaisakhi on Monday. The Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue is sending a greeting message to all Jains for Mahavir Jayanti, which can be found here:…See More
Apr 10
David Coleman posted a video

PALM SUNDAY If you were silent

If the Lord's disciples keep silent, the stones would shout aloud - this is the stones preparing to do so, using 'stones' in a wider sense - the architectura...
Apr 7
Guest Blogs posted a blog post

Love, actually - Nick Baines's blog - Musings of a restless bishop

This is the text of this morning's Pause for Thought on the Chris Evans Show on BBC Radio 2 in the presence of actors Emma Thompson, Celia Imrie, Paul McGann, Sean Pertwee and musician Billy Ocean.I've just been on holiday for a week of culture-free sitting in the sun and reading. It was brilliant. I packed a pile of…See More
Mar 31

© 2014   Created by Churches Together Connect.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service