Questioning the assumptions (again) - Nick Baines's blog - Musings of a restless bishop

Driving over to York this morning I was interested to listen to a piece on the abortion debate on BBC Radio 4. What was intriguing was not the (rather predictable) discussion, but rather the fact that it was the ‘Science Editor’ who commented on it. This betrays the assumption that we are dealing with a medical matter rather than an ethical one. (OK, the bill going through Parliament today would come under that brief, but it still begs the question.)

Maybe I was attuned to this because yesterday I was chairing the Sandford St Martin Trust in London. The Trust’s objective is to ‘promote excellence in religious broadcasting’ and it seeks to do this in a variety of ways, but principally by making prestigious annual awards.

At the Awards Ceremony at Lambeth Palace in May 2010 Roger Bolton made a bold case for the appointment by the BBC of a Religion Editor. He was not asking for an apologist or an evangelist, but an interpreter.

We live in a world in which, whether the commentariat like it or not, religion is (a) a powerful motivator of both individuals and communities, and (b) a social, political, economic and cultural phenomenon – that is, a reality that cannot be simply ignored (because “we don’t like it and wish it wasn’t there”) and cannot be neutered by uncritical assumptions about secular or ‘scientific’ neutrality.

The public discourse needs an interpreter to do for religion what Evan Davies did for economics.

The discussion on the radio this morning was good, but it would have been even better if there had been a brief interpretation or explanation of why different people see things the way they do, derived from the assumptions they assume. If you know what I mean.

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad

Location:Bishopthorpe, York



Views: 11

Tags: Language, Martin, Sandford, St, Trust, broadcasting, journalism, media, religious

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Churches Together Connect to add comments!

Need help?

If you are having any difficulties with Churches Together Connect please contact us by email.


The views expressed on this website, or accessed through links, are those of the people and organisations concerned. CTBI as a charity does not necessarily share these views and accepts no responsibility for them.

Terms and Conditions

Churches Together Connect runs on the network and users are subject to its

Privacy policy

Report an Issue

Latest Activity

Edward Rhodes posted a status
"Last week, between 18th and 25th of Janurary 2015, Skipton and surrounding district celebrated Week of Prayer for Chrisitan Unity. There wer"
Jan 26
Rev Rachel Marszalek updated their profile
Dec 11, 2014
Katharina Smith-Muller posted a blog post

News/Events: Understanding Islam Course

Understanding IslamA four-day course which will be held at Campion Hall, the Jesuit community in Oxford, and aims to help Catholics understand how the worldviews of the Muslims they live and work with are shaped by their faith. The Course takes place between Tuesday 4 November and Friday 7 November 2014. For more information or to book a place visit: See More
Aug 4, 2014
Katharina Smith-Muller posted a blog post

Resources - podcasts on "Understanding Islam"

Dr Damian Howard, SJ, gives a very brief introduction to Islam in in four podcasts, addressing common questions and misunderstandings - ideal material for schools, parishes and individuals who want a sound basis for following the appeal of our bishops to foster and deepen our relationship with people from other religions: More
Jun 10, 2014

© 2015   Created by Churches Together Connect.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service