More meejah matters - Nick Baines's blog - Musings of a restless bishop

Three stories penetrate the work-ridden last few days.

Yesterday Trevor Kavanagh, associate editor and former political editor of the Sun had the nerve to accuse the Metropolitan Police of wasting time and resources on their investigation of criminality at the heart of News International. He described police tactics as treating suspected journalists like “members of an organised crime gang”. He objected to dawn raids and intrusive searches of journalists’ homes.

Forgive my naïveté, but why does he think the police are doing this at all? Would he or his newspaper have had any patience with police ignoring criminality on an industrial scale in some other area of society? Did he consider the handling of the MPs’ expenses scandal as a waste of time and money – a gross overreaction? Does he really think that investigations into corruption and criminality at the Sun is ‘disproportionate’?

I usually find Trevor Kavanagh interesting, but this has left me staggered. Is he so out of touch that he still doesn’t get the public outrage at this enormous corruption? The irony of his choice of words is that the need for expensive and thorough police investigation arises directly from crime that looks distinctly ‘organised’. Or is it just that it is OK for ordinary mortals to have their lives intruded upon, shredded and dumped – their reputations rubbished and their families disturbed – but somehow wrong for journalists to suffer the same treatment? I am boggled.

Richard Dawkins is at it again – although Giles Fraser rattled him on the BBC Radio 4 Today programme this morning. As Dawkins mocked respondents to his poll who couldn’t name the first gospel, Fraser embarrassed him by exposing his inability to remember the full title of Darwin’s Origin of Species. His latest evangelistic campaign is just silly. In danger of confusing atheism with secularism (they are not the same), he perpetuates the pretence that he occupies neutral space whereas religious people are somewhere up the loaded loony scale. What makes him think that his world view is to be privileged above all others is still unclear. Anyway, his survey proves little – and certainly not what he thinks it proves.

Baroness Warsi has complained to the Pope about rampant and aggressive secularism that is marginalising religion in general and Christianity in particular in Britain today. Not having had time today to read all the reports of this, I remain unclear why she needs to tell the Pope what he already thinks. But, the question is really whether or not she is right. I just hope she doesn’t slip into the language of ‘persecution’.

The most interesting two responses I have seen to Dawkins and Warsi are by Giles Fraser and Julian Baggini. Rational atheist argument is fine and secularist campaigning acceptable. But, where does the mindless aggression come from? Why the irrational evangelism that doesn’t even pretend to be tolerant of any world view that differs from it’s own fundamentalism?

 

 

Views: 33

Tags: Baroness, Fraser, Giles, Inquiry, International, Kavanagh, Leveson, News, Sun, Trevor, More…Warsi, atheism, journalism, media, secularism

Comment by Syd Bill on March 14, 2012 at 18:41

Having read copies of the Baroness's speeches at Lambeth Palace and the Vatican I can't see any words

that can be taken as complaining. I think her words as a Muslim are a challenge to Christians and all religions to be active in an increasingly secular world.

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Churches Together Connect to add comments!

Need help?

If you are having any difficulties with Churches Together Connect please contact us by email.

Disclaimer

The views expressed on this website, or accessed through links, are those of the people and organisations concerned. CTBI as a charity does not necessarily share these views and accepts no responsibility for them.

Terms and Conditions

Churches Together Connect runs on the Ning.com network and users are subject to its

Privacy policy

Report an Issue

Latest Activity

Katharina Smith-Muller posted a blog post

Resources - podcasts on "Understanding Islam"

Dr Damian Howard, SJ, gives a very brief introduction to Islam in in four podcasts, addressing common questions and misunderstandings - ideal material for schools, parishes and individuals who want a sound basis for following the appeal of our bishops to foster and deepen our relationship with people from other religions: http://www.catholicnews.org.uk/exploring-islam-podcasts.See More
Jun 10
David Coleman posted a video

ascension reflection

A gentle reflection on themes of the Christian festival of Ascension. Music: Ascent, by Stellardrome, via Jamendo
May 29
Niall Cooper posted a blog post

Launching the Good Society Conversation

Listening to the periphery at the heart of WestminsterThere was something intensely symbolic and powerful about yesterday’s launch of the Good Society Conversation by Churches Together in Britain and Ireland and Church Action on Poverty:  Eighty people packed into the Cardinal Hume Centre’s children’s centre, a stone’s throw from Westminster’s power places – Parliament, Whitehall, Abbey and Cathedral - yet somehow a million miles away from the formalities of what now passes for conventional…See More
May 22
Katharina Smith-Muller posted a blog post

News/events (countrywide) - Buddhists celebrating Buddha day around this time - message from Cardinal Tauran

With slight differences between the traditions, many Buddhists will be celebrating Vesakh, and with it the birth, enlightenment and death of the Buddha, around this time. For the full message to them from Cardinal Tauran, a suggested bidding prayer for Buddhists in this country, and some more information on both the festival and the faith, please go to http://www.catholicnews.org.uk/vesakh-2014.See More
May 16

© 2014   Created by Churches Together Connect.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service